Crime displacement occurs when criminal activity shifts to a different location, time, target, method, or type due to crime prevention measures.
Understanding Crime Displacement
Crime displacement is an important concept in criminology and criminal justice. It refers to the relocation or transformation of criminal activity in response to prevention strategies, law enforcement efforts, or environmental changes. When crime prevention measures make it harder to commit offenses in a specific area, offenders may adapt by finding new ways or places to commit crimes rather than stopping altogether.
While crime displacement can limit the effectiveness of crime prevention programs, it does not always mean that prevention efforts are ineffective. Understanding the different types of displacement and how they interact with crime control strategies can help law enforcement agencies develop better approaches to reducing crime.
Types of Crime Displacement
Crime displacement can take multiple forms, depending on how offenders adjust to new barriers. Scholars have identified six primary types of displacement:
1. Spatial Displacement
Spatial displacement occurs when crime moves from one location to another. For example, if increased police patrols reduce drug dealing in one neighborhood, dealers may relocate to a different area with less law enforcement presence.
2. Temporal Displacement
Temporal displacement happens when offenders shift the timing of their crimes rather than stopping. If security measures are increased at night, burglars may choose to commit offenses during the day when fewer security measures are in place.
3. Target Displacement
In target displacement, criminals change their victims or objects of crime. If car manufacturers improve anti-theft technology in newer vehicles, thieves might start targeting older cars with weaker security.
4. Tactical Displacement
Tactical displacement involves criminals altering their methods to bypass crime prevention efforts. For instance, if banks improve security against armed robbery, criminals might switch to cybercrime or fraud instead.
5. Offense Displacement
Offense displacement occurs when offenders switch to different types of crime. If law enforcement cracks down on street-level drug dealing, some offenders may turn to property crimes like burglary or shoplifting instead.
6. Perpetrator Displacement
Perpetrator displacement happens when one offender stops committing crimes due to crime prevention efforts, but another individual takes their place. This is common in drug markets, where one dealer’s arrest may simply open an opportunity for another to step in.
Theories Behind Crime Displacement
Criminologists have explored crime displacement through different theoretical perspectives. Some key theories that explain this phenomenon include:
Routine Activity Theory
Developed by Lawrence Cohen and Marcus Felson (1979), Routine Activity Theory suggests that crime occurs when a motivated offender encounters a suitable target in the absence of capable guardians. When prevention measures disrupt this balance, criminals may seek alternative targets or locations, leading to displacement.
Rational Choice Theory
Rational Choice Theory, associated with Ronald Clarke and Derek Cornish, argues that offenders make calculated decisions based on risks and rewards. If a crime becomes too risky due to prevention strategies, offenders may choose a different crime, target, or location, causing displacement.
Crime Pattern Theory
Paul and Patricia Brantingham’s Crime Pattern Theory explains that criminals operate within familiar areas known as “awareness spaces.” When prevention measures disrupt these spaces, offenders may shift their activity to new but still familiar locations, leading to spatial displacement.
Does Crime Displacement Always Happen?
One of the most debated questions in criminology is whether crime displacement is inevitable. While displacement does occur in some cases, research shows that it is not always a one-to-one shift. Some crime prevention measures result in a “diffusion of benefits,” meaning that crime reductions extend beyond the targeted area without an increase elsewhere.
For example, studies on hot-spot policing—where police focus on high-crime areas—often find that crime does not simply move to nearby locations. Instead, criminals may be deterred altogether or find it too risky to continue offending. Similarly, improved security measures in public spaces can lead to an overall reduction in crime rather than just shifting it elsewhere.
Crime Displacement vs. Crime Reduction
Understanding crime displacement is crucial for evaluating crime prevention strategies. However, it is also important to recognize that not all crime prevention efforts result in significant displacement. Some key factors influence whether displacement will occur:
- Severity of prevention measures – Stronger and more comprehensive interventions may discourage crime entirely rather than just shifting it.
- Availability of alternative targets – If offenders have limited options, displacement is less likely.
- Offender adaptability – Some criminals are more willing or able to adapt to prevention measures than others.
While some crime displacement is unavoidable, research suggests that well-designed crime prevention programs can still lead to overall reductions in crime.
Strategies to Minimize Crime Displacement
Law enforcement agencies and policymakers can take steps to limit crime displacement and maximize the effectiveness of crime prevention measures. Some strategies include:
- Comprehensive crime prevention plans – Addressing multiple factors at once, such as policing, community engagement, and urban design, can reduce displacement.
- Targeting high-risk offenders – Focusing on repeat offenders and organized criminal networks can prevent others from stepping in when an individual is arrested.
- Using technology and intelligence-led policing – Data-driven approaches can help predict and prevent displacement before it occurs.
- Enhancing guardianship – Strengthening community involvement, increasing surveillance, and improving security measures can make it harder for criminals to find new opportunities.
Conclusion
Crime displacement is a key concern in criminology and criminal justice, as it affects the success of crime prevention strategies. While displacement occurs when offenders adjust to prevention measures by changing locations, times, targets, methods, or crimes, it is not always inevitable. By understanding the different types of displacement and using evidence-based approaches, law enforcement and policymakers can reduce crime effectively without simply shifting it elsewhere.
[ Glossary ]
Last Modified: 02/23/2025