Fantasy Mindscape:
Breathing Life into Characters Through Psychology
17. Tension and Catharsis
In the realm of epic fantasy, conflict isn’t just a narrative device; it’s the lifeblood that courses through every artery of the story, pulsating with urgency and drama. The scale often magnifies, turning personal vendettas into world-changing battles and ethical dilemmas into questions of universal import. Yet, for all its grandiosity, the emotional weight of conflict in epic fantasy should be grounded in the psychological complexities that make any story resonate with its audience. It is understanding these psychological nuances, like tension and catharsis, that can endow an epic tale with the kind of emotional depth that remains etched in readers’ memories long after they’ve turned the last page.
Tension is the psychological experience of conflict in an unresolved state—like a coiled spring, it holds a potential energy that begs for release. Within the framework of epic fantasy, tension often becomes amplified through the lens of magic, mythical creatures, and grand quests. However, the psychological underpinnings remain constant. Characters wrestle with cognitive dissonances, internal dilemmas, and external threats that are relatable on a human level. They may battle dragons, but their true conflict is often with fear, ethical uncertainty, or interpersonal discord. These are the elements that ratchet up the tension, keeping readers invested in the narrative. The more the author can stretch this tension without breaking it, the more satisfying the eventual release—or catharsis—will be.
Catharsis, the emotional purging or release that follows the resolution of conflict, serves as a psychological reset button, re-establishing equilibrium but leaving both characters and readers irrevocably changed. In epic fantasy, the stakes are often life-and-death, shaping entire worlds, societies, or even cosmic balances. These enormous stakes can make the cathartic moment exceptionally impactful, serving not just as a conclusion to a narrative arc, but as a moment of universal significance. Yet, it’s crucial for this release to feel earned; the resolution must be adequate to the scale of the tension that precedes it, whether it is a personal resolution for a character or a seismic shift in the story world.
Psychologically, the cycle of tension and catharsis taps into a basic human need for emotional modulation, a rise and fall that keeps us engaged and invested in the story. It also mirrors our own life experiences of challenge and relief, difficulty and resolution, mirroring the ups and downs that define human existence. Therefore, a well-crafted epic fantasy narrative serves as an exaggerated reflection of our own psychological journeys, complete with the lessons learned and the wisdom earned through conflict and its resolution. It’s this psychological resonance, achieved through careful management of tension and catharsis, that makes epic fantasy not just an escape from reality, but a lens through which we can better understand ourselves and the world around us.
Psychological Theories of Conflict
Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs provides a structured way to understand human motivation and need, and incorporating these layers into an epic fantasy narrative can make for a story rich in both scope and psychological depth. At the base of Maslow’s pyramid are physiological needs, such as food, water, and shelter. In an epic fantasy setting, these elemental needs can translate into quests for magical items that provide sustenance or immortality, or battles to secure arable lands or protect a sacred river. These quests serve not just as thrilling adventures but as foundational efforts to preserve life itself, lending a visceral urgency to the story. When characters are engaged in a struggle for their most basic needs, the stakes are immediately high and relatable, gripping the reader’s attention from the outset.
The next level up on Maslow’s pyramid is the need for safety, which in the realm of epic fantasy could manifest as the struggle against a despotic ruler or a malevolent force threatening the peace and security of the world. Characters might be fighting to protect their city from invading hordes or working to overthrow a tyrant whose rule endangers the lives of the innocent. These conflicts extend beyond the individual, affecting entire communities or nations, and engage the reader on a level that questions what it means to be safe and who holds the power to establish or endanger that safety. Such conflicts add sociopolitical dimensions to your story, offering a more complex narrative lattice for your characters to navigate.
As we ascend further, we encounter the needs for love and belonging, which introduce interpersonal conflicts and relational dynamics into the story. A prince may be torn between love for a commoner and his duty towards his kingdom, or a warrior may struggle with her loyalty to her comrades versus her family. These conflicts are inherently emotional, adding a layer of relational drama that complements the more fundamental struggles occurring at the lower levels of the pyramid. By integrating these interpersonal conflicts, the narrative can explore the nuances of love, friendship, and community, enriching the story and deepening character development.
The need for esteem introduces the concept of personal value and validation, often manifesting in epic fantasy as quests for honor, glory, or some great achievement. A young mage might seek to win a prestigious competition to prove her worth, or a fallen knight may look for redemption on the battlefield to regain his lost honor. Such conflicts offer a glimpse into characters’ internal struggles with self-esteem and societal expectations, adding another dimension of relatability and complexity. The quest for esteem can drive characters to make morally ambiguous decisions, thereby enhancing narrative tension and promoting thematic depth.
Finally, at the apex of Maslow’s hierarchy, we find the need for self-actualization. In epic fantasy, this can take the form of a hero’s journey towards fulfilling their destiny or a character grappling with complex ethical dilemmas and responsibilities of leadership. This ultimate quest for personal fulfillment or universal balance can serve as the backbone of your epic saga, giving the protagonist—and by extension, the reader—a lofty goal towards which all other conflicts and resolutions are oriented. By incorporating the layers of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs into your epic fantasy, you not only elevate the stakes but also create a multi-dimensional tapestry of conflicts that can resonate on multiple levels with the reader, making for a more engaging and psychologically compelling narrative.
Freud’s concept of defense mechanisms offers another rich layer to character development and internal conflict. In epic fantasy, characters often undergo severe trials that bring their deepest fears and insecurities to the surface. They may engage in Freudian defense mechanisms like denial, repression, or projection as they face these internal battles. For instance, a character destined to save the world might be in denial about their role, unwilling to accept the monumental responsibility it entails. Another might project their own fears and insecurities onto a rival or enemy, creating an external conflict that mirrors an internal one. Utilizing these defense mechanisms can make characters more complex and relatable, adding a psychological realism to the epic struggles that define the genre.
Denial serves as a potent defense mechanism, especially in the heightened reality of epic fantasy where characters may face overwhelming burdens or challenges that stretch credulity. A hero chosen by prophecy to defeat a looming evil might engage in denial, refusing to accept the enormity of their designated role. They might dismiss mystical signs, rationalize away mentors’ advice, or even evade challenges that are clearly stepping stones on their path to destiny. This refusal doesn’t just add tension to the plot; it also humanizes the character. Denial becomes a psychological shelter, allowing them to dodge the mental and emotional weight of their destiny, at least temporarily. As readers, we empathize with this retreat into denial, for it reflects our own instinctual desire to avoid uncomfortable truths.
Repression adds another layer of complexity to character development. In the context of epic fantasy, repression can manifest when a character subconsciously hides painful memories or powerful abilities, especially those that could endanger them or the people around them. For example, a mage might repress memories of accidental magic that resulted in tragedy, leading them to doubt or fear their own abilities. Over the course of the story, these repressed elements might surface at critical moments, either as debilitating flashbacks or as unleashed powers, adding depth and unpredictability to both the character and the narrative. Repression serves as both a sword and a shield for the character—protecting them from painful realities but also hobbling their growth and efficacy.
Projection offers a fascinating opportunity to externalize internal conflicts. A character might not only deny or repress their own negative traits, fears, or insecurities but project them onto others. Imagine a royal heir who fears their own incompetence. This character might project that fear onto a younger sibling or a rival noble house, convinced that these other parties are the real threats to the kingdom. Projection like this can serve as the seed for complex political intrigue, feuds, and even wars, all fueled by the protagonist’s or antagonist’s psychological complexities. Moreover, this external conflict then serves as a mirror for internal strife, allowing for multi-dimensional character growth.
In epic fantasy, where character arcs often span multiple books and intricate plots, these Freudian defense mechanisms can serve as nuanced tools for developing psychological realism. Characters aren’t just pawns in a game of good versus evil or simple archetypes fulfilling their roles. They become deeply flawed individuals struggling with their mental barriers, just as any of us do. By weaving denial, repression, and projection into the tapestry of your characters’ lives, you invite readers to see beyond the surface-level conflicts and appreciate the rich psychological landscapes that drive the characters forward or hold them back.
By employing these defense mechanisms, not only do writers enhance individual characters, but they also add layers of depth to interpersonal relationships and broader societal structures in their fantastical worlds. Whether it’s a hero in denial about their fate, a sorcerer repressing their magic, or a queen projecting her insecurities onto a rival kingdom, these psychological intricacies create a more immersive and emotionally resonant experience for the reader. They transform epic fantasy from mere escapism into a complex exploration of human psychology.
The synergy between Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs and Freud’s defense mechanisms can produce extraordinarily nuanced conflicts. For example, a character might ascend to leadership (esteem in Maslow’s terms) but be fraught with insecurities, resorting to Freudian defense mechanisms like displacement or projection to cope. This creates both internal and external conflicts, as the character must conquer their psychological hurdles to fulfill their leadership role effectively. Moreover, a leader’s internal struggle with defense mechanisms can manifest as flaws in governance, affecting the well-being and safety of an entire society, hence touching on the lower levels of Maslow’s hierarchy as well.
In the realm of epic fantasy, where stories often explore the intricacies of good and evil, duty and free will, or love and sacrifice, these psychological theories can inject an authentic emotional gravitas. They offer readers not just an escape but a psychologically intricate world where characters grapple with issues that echo our own psychological complexities. By ensuring that conflicts arise from unmet needs and that characters have authentic psychological reactions to these conflicts, writers can craft epic fantasy narratives that are not just entertaining but emotionally and psychologically resonant.
Integrating theories like Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs and Freud’s defense mechanisms can elevate the conflict in epic fantasy from mere plot devices to profound examinations of human psychology. These theories can serve as foundational pillars for conflict, around which the grand edifices of plot, setting, and character can be constructed. The result is a story that resonates on multiple levels, engaging readers both intellectually and emotionally, providing both spectacle and insight, and leaving an enduring impact long after the final page has been turned.
Conflict in Notable Epic Fantasy
In the realm of epic fantasy, the complexity of conflict is what often sets great works apart. Steven Erikson’s “The Malazan Book of the Fallen” is a prime example of how a variety of conflicts, from the existential to the massively militaristic, can be deeply imbued with psychological nuance. The series dives into philosophical quandaries such as the nature of power, mortality, and the human condition, all set against the backdrop of a world at war. Characters in the series grapple with issues that are not just physical but psychological, dealing with traumas, betrayals, and moral dilemmas that require them to confront the deepest recesses of their souls. This adds a layer of complexity that goes beyond simple good-versus-evil narratives, inviting readers to engage with the story on a more thoughtful and emotionally resonant level.
Joe Abercrombie’s “The First Law Trilogy” takes a different but equally compelling approach to conflict, focusing on the deeply personal and psychological dimensions of its characters’ struggles. Each main character in the trilogy comes with their own set of psychological flaws, insecurities, and fears, making their journeys not just external quests but internal explorations as well.
Whether it’s the bitterness and cynicism of Sand dan Glokta, a torturer who himself was tortured, or the violent temper of Logen Ninefingers, a feared barbarian trying to be a better man, each character’s personal demons inform their decisions and fuel the conflicts in the story. Abercrombie skillfully ties these individual psychological battles back to the larger conflicts in the series, weaving a complex web of tension that keeps readers invested in both the personal and the epic scales of the narrative.
What makes these works notable is their ability to intertwine psychological complexity with the grandeur and spectacle of epic fantasy. In “The Malazan Book of the Fallen,” the grand-scale wars and existential crises serve as a stage for individual characters to confront their own psychological issues. For instance, soldiers not only fight external enemies but also battle their own internal fears and moral uncertainties. In “The First Law Trilogy,” the personal psychological conflicts are not secondary to the plot; they are the plot, driving the characters into situations that then escalate into larger, world-altering events.
The takeaway for both readers and aspiring writers is the enriching effect that psychological depth can have on epic fantasy. By incorporating varied and intricate types of conflict, from the internal psychological battles to grand existential questions and full-scale wars, authors can elevate the genre beyond mere escapism. These kinds of multilayered conflicts offer readers more than just entertainment; they offer a lens through which to examine their own complexities, fears, and moral quandaries.
The intricate tapestry of conflicts seen in works like “The Malazan Book of the Fallen” and “The First Law Trilogy” sets a high standard for epic fantasy. They demonstrate that the most compelling conflicts are those that challenge not only the physical capabilities of characters but also their psychological and moral fiber. By paying attention to the various forms and layers of conflict, from the psychological to the existential, these authors succeed in creating immersive worlds that resonate deeply with readers, achieving a level of complexity and depth that elevates the entire genre.
Crafting Conflict and Resolution
Internal vs. External Conflicts
One of the most effective ways to create a multi-dimensional character in fantasy fiction is to harness psychological theories that explore both internal and external conflicts. According to Sigmund Freud’s model of the human psyche, individuals consist of the id, ego, and superego. Imagine a character who is governed primarily by their id, seeking instant gratification through magic or power. This internal struggle between the id, which demands immediate satisfaction, and the superego, the moral conscience, could manifest externally as well. Such a character may engage in a conflict over whether to use a dangerous spell to save their village, despite the ethical costs. This inner turmoil amplifies the stakes of the external conflict, adding layers of complexity and making the character relatable and flawed.
Erik Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development can also be an invaluable tool for character building. A young protagonist might be at the stage where they are grappling with issues of identity vs. role confusion. External conflicts such as war, familial expectations, or a quest could be a backdrop against which the internal struggle for identity is dramatized. In this case, the external events are not just battles to be won or obstacles to be overcome but are symbolic representations of the internal struggle, thereby interweaving the character’s development arc with the plot.
The Role of Antagonists
Carl Jung’s theory of the “Shadow” aspect of personality is a fantastic resource when developing antagonistic forces in your fantasy world. In Jungian psychology, the “Shadow” refers to the darker, unconscious aspects of ourselves that we might not acknowledge or might actively repress. An antagonist who embodies the protagonist’s shadow elements serves not just as a hurdle to overcome but as a mirror reflecting the protagonist’s own weaknesses, fears, or repressed desires. For example, if the protagonist is a disciplined mage guided by rationality, the antagonist could be a chaotic sorcerer who embraces the irrational, embodying the protagonist’s suppressed fears about the uncontrollable aspects of magic or their own nature.
Additionally, villains crafted with Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs in mind can add further psychological depth to your story. Perhaps the antagonist and the protagonist share an unfulfilled need for “self-actualization,” but their methods for achieving it are diametrically opposed. The antagonist may resort to cruelty or tyranny to reach a state of self-fulfillment, seeing it as the quickest path to attain their needs at the top of Maslow’s pyramid. This sets up a scenario where the protagonist must confront their own unfulfilled needs and potential shortcuts to achieving them, challenging their morals and values in the process.
Employing psychological theories can provide a rich scaffold upon which to build characters that are not merely black or white but exist in shades of gray. When a character’s internal and external conflicts are orchestrated using these psychological frameworks, the resulting emotional complexity adds a level of realism and relatability to your fantasy fiction. Similarly, antagonists developed through these psychological lenses become more than mere obstacles; they become crucial elements in the protagonist’s journey toward self-discovery and growth.
Writing Exercises for Crafting Conflict
Moral Dilemma: Write a scene where a character faces a moral dilemma that causes internal psychological conflict.
Cathartic Resolution: Create a scene that provides psychological catharsis for a character, resolving a long-standing conflict in a satisfying manner.
By infusing psychological theories into your conflict and resolution mechanisms, you can craft a story that not only entertains but also delves deep into the human psyche. The tension and catharsis experienced by the reader will be all the more potent for its psychological underpinnings.
[ 16. The Psychology of Magic | Contents | 18. Nature vs. Nurture ]
Last Modified: 10/05/2023