primary deviance

Primary deviance refers to initial acts of rule-breaking that do not result in a person being labeled as deviant by society

Understanding Primary Deviance

Definition of Primary Deviance

Primary deviance refers to the first instances of rule-breaking behavior that individuals engage in. These initial acts are often minor and do not result in the individual being labeled as a deviant by society. Edwin Lemert, a sociologist, introduced the concept to differentiate between occasional rule-breaking and more serious, repetitive deviant behavior, which he termed secondary deviance.

Characteristics of Primary Deviance

Minor Rule-breaking

Primary deviance typically involves minor violations of social norms or laws, such as petty theft, minor vandalism, or underage drinking. These acts are often seen as part of growing up or as isolated incidents.

Lack of Social Reaction

One key feature of primary deviance is that it does not attract significant negative attention or reactions from society. Since these acts are not severe, they do not result in the individual being stigmatized or labeled as a deviant.

No Change in Self-Identity

During primary deviance, the individual does not see themselves as deviant. They consider their actions as isolated events that do not define their identity or alter how they are perceived by others.

Causes of Primary Deviance

Social Influences

Primary deviance can be influenced by social factors such as peer pressure, family dynamics, or cultural norms. For example, teenagers might engage in minor rule-breaking to fit in with their friends or to rebel against parental authority.

Situational Factors

Situational factors, like being in the wrong place at the wrong time, can also lead to primary deviance. Sometimes, individuals commit minor offenses due to opportunity or circumstantial pressure, rather than a deliberate intention to break the law.

Psychological Factors

Personal characteristics, including impulsiveness or a lack of awareness about the consequences of their actions, can also contribute to primary deviance. Young people, in particular, may not fully understand the long-term impacts of their behavior.

Impact of Primary Deviance

Primary deviance usually has minimal impact on the individual and society, but it can play a role in the development of more serious deviant behavior if not addressed.

Limited Consequences

Since primary deviance involves minor acts, the immediate consequences are often minimal. Individuals might face small fines, warnings, or mild disapproval, but these reactions typically do not lead to lasting stigma or punishment.

Potential for Escalation

If primary deviance goes unaddressed, it can lead to more serious rule-breaking behavior, known as secondary deviance. This escalation occurs when minor acts become habitual, or when individuals begin to associate with others who engage in more severe deviant behaviors.

Differentiating Primary and Secondary Deviance

Involves minor rule-breaking.
Does not lead to significant societal reaction.
The individual does not view themselves as deviant.

Secondary Deviance

Involves repeated or more serious rule-breaking.
Results in societal labeling and stigmatization.
The individual begins to adopt a deviant identity.

Addressing Primary Deviance

Early Intervention

Addressing primary deviance through early intervention can prevent the escalation to secondary deviance. Programs focused on education, counseling, and community support can help individuals understand the consequences of their actions and develop healthier behaviors.

Positive Reinforcement

Encouraging positive behavior through reinforcement and rewards can help steer individuals away from rule-breaking. Recognizing and rewarding good behavior can be more effective than punishing minor infractions.

Role of Families and Schools

Families and schools play a crucial role in addressing primary deviance. By fostering open communication, setting clear expectations, and providing guidance, they can help young people navigate challenges and make better choices.

Societal Perspective on Primary Deviance

Understanding Context

Society benefits from understanding the context of primary deviance. Recognizing that minor rule-breaking is often a part of development can help create more supportive and rehabilitative responses rather than punitive ones.

Reducing Stigma

Reducing the stigma associated with minor deviant acts can prevent individuals from being unfairly labeled. This approach encourages individuals to learn from their mistakes without the burden of a deviant identity.

Examples of Primary Deviance

Primary deviance includes minor rule-breaking or norm violations that are often seen as isolated incidents rather than indicators of deviant identity. Here are several examples:

1. Underage Drinking

Many young people try alcohol before the legal age, often seen as typical adolescent behavior. Occasional underage drinking generally doesn’t result in long-term labels or social stigma.

2. Minor Shoplifting

Taking small items, like candy or makeup, is a common example of impulsive behavior. When it’s a one-time occurrence, the individual is not usually labeled a “thief,” and consequences are often minor.

3. Skipping School

Occasionally skipping classes to socialize or avoid a test is often seen as teenage rebellion rather than a sign of deeper issues. Most students don’t face lasting repercussions if it’s infrequent.

4. Minor Vandalism

Acts like drawing on a desk or scratching initials into a surface are usually dismissed as pranks. Society tends to respond with minor consequences, avoiding long-term labels.

5. Traffic Violations

Many people engage in minor traffic violations, such as speeding slightly or rolling through a stop sign. Unless these behaviors are habitual or dangerous, they rarely lead to serious societal labeling.

6. Experimenting with Substances

Trying cigarettes or marijuana in social settings is often part of youth exploration. Occasional experimentation, especially if brief, typically isn’t seen as part of one’s identity.

7. Public Disturbances

Actions like shouting or playing loud music in a park might prompt a warning from authorities but are often viewed as minor and temporary disruptions rather than serious offenses.

These examples of primary deviance highlight behaviors that are typically considered isolated incidents. Without repeated actions or escalation, society’s response is generally mild, helping individuals avoid a deviant label and allowing them to learn without lasting consequences.

Conclusion

Primary deviance involves initial acts of rule-breaking that do not lead to a deviant label. Understanding and addressing primary deviance can prevent the escalation to more serious behaviors and help individuals maintain a positive self-identity. Society can effectively manage primary deviance and promote healthy development by fostering supportive environments and early interventions.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) about Primary Deviance

Q1: What is the difference between primary deviance and secondary deviance, according to Lemert?

A: Edwin Lemert, a sociologist, distinguished between primary and secondary deviance to describe different stages of rule-breaking behavior. Primary deviance refers to initial, minor acts of deviance that are often isolated and do not lead to the individual being labeled as deviant by society. These acts typically don’t alter the person’s self-identity. Secondary deviance, however, occurs when an individual continues or escalates deviant behavior and is publicly labeled as “deviant” by others. This labeling can lead to a shift in identity, where the person internalizes the deviant label, seeing themselves as different from mainstream society and possibly engaging in more deviant behavior.

Q2: Why doesn’t primary deviance lead to long-term consequences?

A: Primary deviance usually involves minor, isolated actions that don’t carry a significant social stigma. Society often sees these actions as normal parts of development or impulsive mistakes. Because of this, people who engage in primary deviance are rarely labeled, allowing them to continue without adopting a deviant identity.

Q3: Can primary deviance lead to secondary deviance?

A: Yes, primary deviance can lead to secondary deviance if minor rule-breaking becomes habitual or if others label the individual as deviant. For example, repeated shoplifting might lead to an arrest, which could result in the person being publicly labeled as a “criminal.” This stigma can influence the person to adopt the deviant identity, potentially leading to more serious or persistent deviant behavior.

Q4: What are some real-world examples of primary deviance?

A: Common examples of primary deviance include underage drinking, minor shoplifting, occasional truancy, minor vandalism, and small traffic violations. These behaviors are usually treated as isolated incidents or youthful mistakes and don’t result in lasting labels unless they escalate.

Q5: How does society typically respond to primary deviance?

A: Society often responds to primary deviance with mild consequences, such as warnings, fines, or educational interventions, rather than serious penalties. This approach helps avoid stigmatizing individuals over minor rule-breaking, which can prevent the behavior from escalating into secondary deviance.

Go to top

References and Further Reading

Piven, F. F. (1980). Deviant Behavior and the Remaking of the World. Soc. Probs., 28, 489.