Total institution refers to a place where people live under strict control, with all aspects of life regulated by authorities, often isolated from wider society.
Introduction to Total Institution
The concept of a “total institution” was introduced by sociologist Erving Goffman in his 1961 book Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. A total institution is defined as a highly structured environment where people live and work, cut off from wider society, with all aspects of their lives controlled by an authority. These institutions are designed to regulate the behavior of their residents and often aim to reshape their identity or behavior.
Total institutions can take many forms, such as prisons, military boot camps, psychiatric hospitals, boarding schools, convents, and even nursing homes. Each of these settings shares the common characteristic of enforcing strict routines, isolating individuals from the outside world, and having a single authority figure or system in charge.
Key Characteristics of Total Institutions
Total institutions are unique in the way they structure life for their inhabitants. Goffman outlined five key features that define a total institution:
- Isolation from Society: Individuals are physically separated from the outside world, often having little contact with family, friends, or wider society.
- Strict Control Over Daily Life: Authorities regulate all aspects of the individual’s daily activities, including when they eat, sleep, work, and interact with others.
- Routine and Uniformity: Life in a total institution is highly regimented, with fixed schedules and rules that apply equally to all residents.
- Enforced Hierarchy: A clear chain of command exists, with a small group of staff or administrators holding power over the large group of residents.
- Loss of Personal Identity: Individuals in total institutions often lose aspects of their personal identity, adopting instead the roles and rules imposed by the institution.
Types of Total Institutions
Total institutions serve different purposes, and they can be categorized into several types based on their function. Each type of institution operates with a unique set of rules and objectives, but they all follow the general characteristics of control, isolation, and strict regulation.
Prisons
Prisons are perhaps the most well-known example of a total institution. Inmates are separated from society as punishment for crimes and live under strict control. Every aspect of their daily routine, from meals to recreational activities, is dictated by prison authorities. Inmates often experience a loss of autonomy, and their time in prison is meant to reshape their behavior according to society’s legal and moral standards.
Mental Hospitals and Asylums
Psychiatric institutions or asylums are designed to treat individuals with mental illnesses. In these settings, patients are often confined for long periods and subjected to treatments aimed at modifying their behavior or treating their conditions. Goffman’s work focused on mental hospitals as total institutions, examining how these environments isolate individuals and deprive them of their personal freedom and identity.
Military Boot Camps
Military boot camps are another form of total institution. New recruits are separated from civilian life and immersed in a highly structured, hierarchical environment where discipline and conformity are emphasized. The goal is to train individuals to follow orders without question and to mold them into soldiers who prioritize the collective over personal desires. In these institutions, strict routines and physical challenges are part of the re-socialization process.
Boarding Schools and Religious Orders
Boarding schools and religious orders, such as convents and monasteries, can also function as total institutions. Students or members of these institutions live apart from the rest of society and follow strict rules, often aimed at moral or spiritual development. The daily routine is highly regulated, and personal freedoms may be limited in order to focus on education or religious devotion.
Nursing Homes
Nursing homes, where elderly residents live under constant supervision, can be considered a form of total institution as well. While not as rigid or punitive as other types, nursing homes often isolate residents from their former lives and enforce routines for meals, medication, and recreation. The environment can lead to a loss of personal autonomy and identity for residents.
Social Dynamics within Total Institutions
Living in a total institution dramatically alters the social dynamics and interactions between individuals. The rigid structure and isolation of these environments affect both the residents and the staff who enforce the rules. Goffman’s analysis of total institutions explored how these dynamics operate and the impact they have on personal identity and social relations.
The Role of the “Inmate” and the “Staff”
In total institutions, there is a sharp division between the residents (often called “inmates” by Goffman, though this term can apply broadly) and the staff. The staff hold all the power and enforce the rules, while the inmates have little or no control over their own lives. This unequal power dynamic creates a clear social hierarchy, with the staff holding authority and the inmates expected to obey.
Staff members are tasked with maintaining order and ensuring that inmates follow the institution’s rules. This often requires staff to act impersonally, reinforcing the sense of dehumanization that can occur in total institutions. Inmates, on the other hand, may resist the rules in subtle ways, attempting to maintain some sense of personal autonomy or identity. This can lead to tensions between the two groups.
The Loss of Identity
One of the most profound effects of living in a total institution is the erosion of personal identity. Inmates often lose their sense of individuality as they are forced to conform to the institution’s rules and routines. For example, in prisons or mental hospitals, individuals may be stripped of their personal belongings, required to wear uniforms, and referred to by numbers rather than names. This process of de-personalization helps the institution maintain control but can lead to feelings of alienation and loss of self.
Re-socialization
A key function of many total institutions is to re-socialize individuals—to strip away their previous identity and replace it with a new one that fits the institution’s goals. In military boot camps, for instance, recruits are taught to adopt the identity of a soldier, prioritizing obedience, discipline, and teamwork. In psychiatric hospitals, patients might be encouraged to see themselves as “sick” individuals in need of treatment. This re-socialization process can be effective in some cases, but it can also be psychologically damaging, as individuals struggle to reconcile their old identity with the new one imposed on them.
Impact of Total Institutions on Society
Total institutions not only affect the individuals living within them but also have broader implications for society. These institutions serve to regulate behavior, enforce social norms, and maintain order, particularly in situations where individuals are seen as deviating from societal expectations. However, they also raise important ethical and social questions about autonomy, freedom, and human rights.
Social Control and Deviance
Total institutions are a form of social control, designed to manage individuals who are considered deviant or problematic by society. Prisons, for example, confine people who have broken the law, while psychiatric hospitals house those deemed mentally unwell. By isolating and controlling these individuals, total institutions help to reinforce societal norms and prevent deviance from spreading. However, critics argue that these institutions can be overly punitive, sometimes treating individuals as problems to be controlled rather than as people in need of help.
Human Rights and Ethics
Total institutions raise ethical questions about the treatment of individuals, particularly when it comes to autonomy and freedom. In environments where all aspects of life are controlled, residents may be deprived of basic rights, such as privacy, self-expression, and freedom of movement. Critics of total institutions argue that these settings can be dehumanizing, leading to abuse or neglect of the people they are meant to serve. This has led to calls for reforms in how such institutions are structured and managed, with a greater focus on respecting the dignity and rights of residents.
Conclusion
Total institutions are powerful social structures that shape the lives of individuals by controlling and regulating their behavior. Through isolation, routine, and strict authority, these institutions attempt to re-socialize their residents, often stripping them of personal identity and autonomy. While total institutions serve important functions in society, such as maintaining order and addressing deviance, they also raise significant ethical concerns. Understanding the dynamics of total institutions provides valuable insight into how societies control behavior, enforce norms, and manage individuals who deviate from accepted standards.
References and Further Reading
- Kallman, M. E. (2018). Teaching sociology in a men’s prison: How total institutions shape pedagogy and engagement with content. Teaching Sociology, 46(4), 295-308.
Learn More
On This Site
Modification History File Created: 09/19/2024 Last Modified: 09/20/2024
This work is licensed under an Open Educational Resource-Quality Master Source (OER-QMS) License.
