The Big Five personality traits—openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism—offer a psychological framework for understanding behavior, including criminal tendencies.
Personality and Criminal Behavior
Personality plays a crucial role in shaping how individuals interact with the world around them. In criminology, researchers have long sought to understand how personality traits influence criminal behavior, recidivism, and rehabilitation. One of the most widely accepted models for studying personality is the Big Five, a framework that categorizes human personality into five broad dimensions. Each of these traits exists on a spectrum, meaning people exhibit varying degrees of them. While personality alone does not determine criminality, certain traits are consistently associated with a higher likelihood of engaging in unlawful or antisocial behavior.
Understanding the relationship between personality and crime helps criminologists, psychologists, and law enforcement professionals assess risk factors, predict behavior, and design rehabilitation programs. By analyzing the Big Five traits, researchers can gain insight into why some individuals are more prone to impulsivity, aggression, or antisocial behavior while others demonstrate strong self-control and prosocial attitudes.
The Development of the Big Five Model
The Big Five model emerged from decades of psychological research. Early personality theorists, including Raymond Cattell and Hans Eysenck, attempted to classify personality into measurable traits. However, it was Lewis Goldberg in the 1980s who formally outlined the Big Five, drawing from earlier lexical studies that examined how language reflects personality. Through statistical analysis, researchers identified five distinct yet broad dimensions of personality that consistently appeared across different cultures and populations. This model has since become a cornerstone in personality psychology, providing a structured approach to understanding individual differences.
In criminology, the Big Five framework has been particularly useful in explaining behavioral tendencies that contribute to criminal activity. By examining how each trait influences decision-making, impulse control, and social interactions, researchers can better understand the underlying psychological factors that make certain individuals more susceptible to criminal behavior.
Examining the Five Traits in Criminal Justice
Each of the Big Five traits contributes uniquely to personality and behavior. Some traits, such as conscientiousness and agreeableness, serve as protective factors against crime, while others, such as low conscientiousness or high neuroticism, may increase the likelihood of engaging in delinquent activities.
Openness to experience reflects an individual’s willingness to explore new ideas, embrace change, and engage in creative thinking. Those high in openness are often curious, imaginative, and open-minded, while those low in openness prefer routine, structure, and familiarity. In criminology, openness does not have a direct link to criminal behavior, but it can play a role in risk-taking. Individuals who score high in openness may be more likely to experiment with deviant behaviors or challenge societal norms, though this does not necessarily translate into criminal activity. Conversely, those with low openness may resist change, which can impact rehabilitation efforts if they are unwilling to adapt to new ways of thinking or behaving.
Conscientiousness is one of the most significant traits when examining criminal behavior. It refers to an individual’s level of self-discipline, organization, and impulse control. People high in conscientiousness tend to be responsible, goal-oriented, and reliable, while those low in conscientiousness are often impulsive, careless, and prone to risk-taking. Research consistently shows that low conscientiousness is a strong predictor of criminal activity. Individuals who struggle with self-regulation may engage in reckless or antisocial behaviors, including theft, drug use, or violent crime. This trait is particularly important in recidivism studies, as those with low conscientiousness may find it difficult to change their behaviors even after being punished.
Extraversion describes a person’s level of social engagement, energy, and enthusiasm. Highly extraverted individuals are outgoing, assertive, and enjoy stimulation, while introverted individuals are more reserved and prefer solitude. The link between extraversion and crime is complex. Some research suggests that high extraversion, particularly when combined with low conscientiousness, can contribute to impulsivity and risk-taking behavior. Individuals with high extraversion may seek excitement, which can lead to delinquent activities such as reckless driving, substance abuse, or thrill-seeking crimes. However, extraversion alone is not a definitive predictor of criminal behavior. In some cases, socially dominant individuals use their extraversion to manipulate others, particularly in fraud or white-collar crimes.
Agreeableness is closely associated with empathy, kindness, and cooperation. Highly agreeable individuals tend to be compassionate, trusting, and considerate of others, while those low in agreeableness may be suspicious, manipulative, or aggressive. In criminology, low agreeableness is strongly linked to antisocial behavior. Individuals who lack empathy or disregard the feelings of others are more likely to engage in violent crimes, deceitful acts, or exploitative behavior. Many offenders diagnosed with antisocial personality disorder or psychopathy score low in agreeableness, indicating a disregard for societal norms and the well-being of others. On the other hand, individuals high in agreeableness are less likely to engage in criminal behavior, as they prioritize maintaining positive relationships and avoiding harm to others.
Neuroticism refers to emotional stability and the tendency to experience negative emotions such as anxiety, anger, or depression. Those high in neuroticism often struggle with emotional regulation, experiencing frequent mood swings, stress, or impulsive reactions. In criminology, high neuroticism is associated with increased aggression and impulsive crimes. Individuals who struggle with frustration tolerance or anger management may be more prone to violent behavior, particularly in emotionally charged situations. Additionally, neurotic individuals may turn to substance abuse as a coping mechanism, increasing their likelihood of engaging in drug-related offenses. However, neuroticism alone does not necessarily lead to crime; rather, it interacts with other factors such as environmental stressors and social influences.
Personality, Risk Assessment, and Rehabilitation
Understanding personality traits is valuable in both predicting criminal behavior and designing effective rehabilitation programs. Psychological assessments based on the Big Five can help criminal justice professionals determine an individual’s risk of reoffending. For example, offenders with low conscientiousness and high neuroticism may benefit from targeted interventions that focus on impulse control and emotional regulation.
Rehabilitation programs that consider personality traits are often more successful in reducing recidivism. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), for instance, has been shown to help individuals with high neuroticism manage their emotions more effectively. Similarly, structured programs that emphasize responsibility and self-discipline can be beneficial for individuals with low conscientiousness. By tailoring rehabilitation efforts to an offender’s personality profile, the criminal justice system can improve rehabilitation outcomes and reduce repeat offenses.
Limitations of the Big Five Model in Criminology
While the Big Five personality traits provide valuable insights into criminal behavior, they are not the sole determinants of crime. Many other factors, including social influences, economic conditions, and childhood experiences, contribute to an individual’s likelihood of engaging in criminal activity. Personality assessments should be used in conjunction with other risk factors rather than as definitive predictors of criminal behavior.
Additionally, personality traits are not fixed. People can change over time, especially with intervention, therapy, or changes in their environment. This means that while personality assessments can provide useful guidance, they should not be seen as permanent labels. Furthermore, the Big Five model is broad and does not account for more specific traits that are particularly relevant in criminology, such as psychopathy or impulsivity.
Conclusion
The Big Five personality traits offer a structured way to understand the psychological factors that contribute to criminal behavior. While traits like low conscientiousness and low agreeableness are strong predictors of antisocial behavior, personality alone does not determine criminality. Instead, it interacts with environmental and social influences to shape an individual’s behavior. By incorporating personality assessments into risk evaluation and rehabilitation efforts, the criminal justice system can develop more effective strategies for reducing crime and supporting rehabilitation. Understanding the complexities of personality provides valuable insights, but it should always be considered alongside other critical factors that influence criminal behavior.
[ Glossary ]
Last Modified: 02/22/2025