Section 2.2: The Greeks and Romans

The philosophies of ancient Greece and Rome have profoundly shaped the contours of Western political thought, laying the foundational stones upon which modern criminology is built. These classical civilizations did not just contribute to the arts and sciences; they also forged the earliest concepts of justice, law, and governance, which continue to influence our understanding of crime and criminal behavior.

Reading Time: 11 minutes

Greek philosophers, such as Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, delved deep into questions of ethics, justice, and the ideal state. Their explorations into the nature of virtue, the role of the individual in society, and the foundations of moral conduct provided early frameworks for understanding human behavior in both lawful and unlawful contexts. Their ideas not only shaped the philosophical landscape but also sowed the seeds for the development of legal systems and criminological thought.

In parallel, Roman thinkers and jurists like Cicero and Seneca contributed significantly to the development of legal systems and philosophy. They expanded upon Greek ideas, emphasizing the role of law in society and individual rights. The Romans were pioneers in creating detailed legal systems, laying down principles that form the bedrock of modern Western legal systems.

Together, these ancient Greek and Roman philosophies form a crucial part of the tapestry of Western political thought, their legacies enduring through centuries, continuing to inform and shape the field of criminology.

Greek Philosophy and its Influence

The cradle of Western philosophy, ancient Greece, was home to some of the most influential thinkers whose ideas on justice and law laid the groundwork for modern criminological thought. Socrates, with his method of inquiry and emphasis on ethical living, pushed for a deeper understanding of moral concepts, including justice. Plato, Socrates’ student, expanded these ideas in his works, most notably in “The Republic,” where he envisioned an ideal state governed by philosopher-kings, guided by wisdom and justice. Plato’s thoughts on the just society and the role of law in maintaining order have been profoundly influential.

Aristotle, a student of Plato, further developed these ideas, focusing on the practical application of ethics and politics. He saw law as a means to achieve the ‘good life,’ emphasizing the importance of virtue and rationality in governance. Aristotle’s “Nicomachean Ethics” and “Politics” offer insights into the nature of justice, advocating for laws that promote the common good. These early Greek philosophers not only shaped philosophical discourse but also laid the foundational ideas for legal and criminological systems.

The Concept of Justice in Greek Philosophy

Greek philosophy’s treatment of justice was revolutionary for its time and remains influential. Plato’s concept of justice in “The Republic” is tied to his vision of an ideal society, where justice prevails when everyone performs their designated role harmoniously. He argued that a just society is one where rulers are wise, soldiers are courageous, and producers are disciplined, each class contributing to a harmonious whole.

Aristotle’s approach in his “Nicomachean Ethics” was more individualistic, focusing on virtue ethics. He contended that justice is a virtue, central to ethical human behavior, and that a just person is one who possesses and practices moral virtues. Aristotle saw laws as crucial in cultivating virtues among citizens, thereby achieving justice.

These conceptualizations of justice in Greek philosophy contributed to the understanding of what constitutes a fair and equitable society, the role of individuals within it, and the importance of laws in maintaining societal balance and morality.

Greek Contributions to Criminological Thought

The philosophical legacies of ancient Greece have permeated modern criminological thought and legal systems. The Socratic method of inquiry laid the groundwork for critical thinking and analysis, essential in criminological research and legal proceedings. Plato’s ideas on the ideal state and the role of justice have influenced theories of social order and the functioning of legal institutions.

Aristotle’s emphasis on rationality and virtue ethics has had a lasting impact on legal philosophy, particularly in the concepts of natural justice and equity. His belief in law as a means to achieve the common good is echoed in contemporary legal systems that aim to balance individual rights with societal welfare.

The Greek philosophers’ exploration of ethics, justice, and the role of law also provided early frameworks for understanding criminal behavior. Their focus on rationality, virtue, and the social structure’s influence on individual behavior are themes that resonate in modern criminological theories. The ancient Greek pursuit of understanding human nature and society set the stage for an evolving discourse on crime, punishment, and justice, influencing the development of both criminological theory and legal practice.

Roman Philosophy and Legal Systems

Roman law, with its comprehensive legal structures and philosophies, has significantly influenced Western legal systems. The development of Roman law was characterized by a pragmatic approach that evolved to meet the complex needs of an expanding empire. Central to Roman legal philosophy was the concept of ‘jus civile’ (civil law), the law applicable to Roman citizens, and ‘jus gentium’ (law of nations), which governed the affairs between Romans and non-Romans.

The Romans were pioneers in codifying laws, an effort epitomized by the Twelve Tables, which laid down the basis for Roman civil law. Their legal system was marked by a high degree of flexibility and adaptability, integrating customs, judicial precedents, and legislative decrees. Roman law’s emphasis on concrete, practical legislation rather than abstract philosophical ideals distinguished it from Greek law. It focused on the rights and duties of citizens, legal procedures, property rights, and family law, setting foundations that would greatly influence modern legal doctrines.

Influential Roman Thinkers: Cicero and Others

Among Roman thinkers, Cicero stands out for his substantial contributions to legal and ethical thought. A lawyer and philosopher, Cicero introduced the concept of ‘natural law’ (lex naturalis), arguing that certain legal principles are inherent in human nature and can be discerned through reason. His work emphasized justice, the rule of law, and the importance of virtuous leadership.

Cicero’s writings on law and ethics, especially in “De Legibus” (On the Laws) and “De Republica” (On the Republic), were influential in shaping the Roman legal system and later Western legal and political thought. His ideas on the universality of certain legal principles laid the groundwork for the development of international law and human rights.

Other Roman jurists and thinkers, like Ulpian and Gaius, contributed to the systematization of Roman law, further enhancing its clarity, coherence, and efficiency. Their work in categorizing laws and legal principles was crucial in the formation of legal systems in later European civilizations.

Roman Influence on Modern Criminology

The influence of Roman legal principles and philosophies on contemporary criminology is profound. Roman law’s pragmatic approach, emphasis on codification, and development of legal categories have shaped modern legal systems and criminological practices. The Roman concept of ‘mens rea’ (guilty mind) and the distinction between different types of criminal intent are foundational in contemporary criminal law.

The methodical categorization of crimes and legal procedures in Roman law has influenced modern legal systems’ structure and operation. This systematic approach aids in the clear understanding and application of laws, an essential aspect of effective criminological practice.

Furthermore, the Roman emphasis on justice and the rule of law continues to resonate in modern legal systems. Concepts like due process, equity, and the universality of certain legal principles are echoes of Roman thought, underpinning contemporary debates in criminology and legal philosophy. The Roman legacy, thus, lives on, significantly impacting the way laws are framed, interpreted, and applied in modern societies.

Greek and Roman Views on Crime and Punishment

The ancient Greeks held a nuanced perspective on crime and law, deeply intertwined with their philosophical and societal values. Greek views on crime were not solely punitive; they also encompassed a strong sense of moral and civic responsibility.

In Athens, one of the most developed city-states, the legal system was characterized by its democratic approach. Lawmaking was a collective endeavor, and citizens played a direct role in judicial proceedings. The Greeks perceived crime as not only a violation against an individual but also as an offense against the polis (city-state). Hence, maintaining social order and protecting public morality were central to their legal practices.

Punishments in ancient Greece varied depending on the nature of the crime and could include fines, exile, or even death. However, Greek law also showed a tendency towards rehabilitation. For instance, the concept of ‘atimia’ (loss of honor) was a form of punishment that emphasized social disgrace over physical suffering.

Greek legal philosophy, especially as articulated by Plato and Aristotle, had a significant impact on their views of crime and punishment. Plato’s ideal state proposed a society governed by philosopher-kings, where justice prevailed through the moral education of citizens rather than through coercion. Aristotle, in his “Nicomachean Ethics,” advocated for proportionality in punishment, arguing that penalties should be commensurate with the severity of the crime and aim at the moral improvement of the offender.

These perspectives reveal the Greeks’ emphasis on ethical conduct, civic duty, and the role of law in cultivating virtue, influencing the way crime was perceived and addressed in their society.

Roman Approaches to Crime and Justice

Roman approaches to crime and justice were markedly pragmatic, reflecting their emphasis on order and governance. The Romans developed a comprehensive legal system that detailed various crimes and corresponding punishments, and they were pioneers in categorizing law into different branches such as civil and criminal law.

In the Roman legal system, crimes were seen as offenses against the state, and the emphasis was on maintaining public order and protecting property rights. Roman law was codified, allowing for more consistency and predictability in its application. The legal procedures were formal and complex, involving various stages including accusation, evidence gathering, and trial.

Punishments in Roman law were often severe and included fines, exile, corporal punishment, and execution. The Romans also introduced the notion of ‘poena publica’ (public punishment), where certain crimes were subject to public penalties as a means of deterrence and maintaining social order.

Notably, Roman law introduced important legal principles that are still relevant today, such as ‘mens rea’ (guilty mind) and ‘actus reus’ (guilty act), which differentiated between the intent and the act of crime. This distinction was crucial in determining culpability and the appropriate level of punishment.

The Roman approach to crime and justice, with its emphasis on codified laws, formal legal procedures, and public punishment, laid the groundwork for many aspects of modern Western legal systems, including the principles of due process and the rule of law.

Comparative Analysis: Greeks vs. Romans 

The philosophical and legal approaches of the Greeks and Romans, while sharing some common ground, diverge in significant ways, reflecting their unique cultural and societal values.\

Greek philosophy, deeply rooted in intellectual and ethical inquiry, emphasized the role of individual virtue and moral education in achieving justice. Greek thinkers like Plato and Aristotle focused on the idea of an ideal state where law and governance were based on ethical principles and the moral development of citizens. The Greek legal system, particularly in democratic city-states like Athens, was more participatory, with citizens actively involved in the judicial process. This approach reflected a belief in the collective responsibility of maintaining social order and moral standards.

In contrast, Roman philosophy and legal systems were more pragmatic and utilitarian. The Romans developed a highly structured legal code, focusing on the practical aspects of governance and public order. Their legal system was more rigid and formalized, with a clear distinction between different types of laws and a focus on concrete legal procedures. Roman legal thought, as seen in the works of Cicero, emphasized the importance of stability, order, and the protection of the state and property rights.

These contrasting approaches highlight a fundamental difference: while the Greeks focused on the moral and ethical dimensions of law and justice, the Romans emphasized the practical and procedural aspects. This divergence in focus and methodology between Greek and Roman philosophies offers a rich tapestry of legal and ethical thought that has influenced Western civilization.

Implications for Modern Criminological Theory

The differing philosophical legacies of the Greeks and Romans have had lasting implications for modern criminological theory. The Greek emphasis on ethics, civic responsibility, and the moral education of citizens resonates in contemporary theories that focus on the social and psychological aspects of criminal behavior. Concepts such as rehabilitation, restorative justice, and the social contract theory, which emphasize the moral and ethical development of individuals and their integration into society, echo Greek thought.

On the other hand, the Roman legacy of a structured legal system, codification of laws, and focus on public order and legal procedures have influenced criminological theories that emphasize the role of law, the state, and formal institutions in controlling and preventing crime. The Roman approach can be seen in theories that prioritize the effectiveness of the criminal justice system, the rule of law, and the deterrence of criminal behavior through legal sanctions.

These differing philosophical traditions provide a comprehensive framework for understanding the multifaceted nature of crime and justice. The integration of Greek and Roman ideas in modern criminological thought reflects a balanced approach that considers both the ethical/moral dimensions and the practical/legal aspects of criminology, contributing to a more holistic understanding of criminal behavior and justice systems.

Summary and Conclusions 

The exploration of Greek and Roman philosophies reveals their enduring influence on the field of Western criminology. These ancient civilizations laid the foundational blocks of legal and ethical thought, providing perspectives and principles that continue to resonate in modern criminological theories and practices.

Greek philosophy, with its emphasis on ethics, virtue, and the ideal state, introduced concepts of justice and morality that have profoundly shaped the way we understand criminal behavior and societal responses to it. The democratic nature of Greek legal systems, particularly in Athens, and the philosophical inquiries of thinkers like Plato and Aristotle, fostered an approach to criminology that values moral education, civic responsibility, and the ethical dimensions of law and governance.

In contrast, Roman philosophy and legal systems, characterized by their pragmatic and structured approach, contributed significantly to the development of formal legal procedures, codification of laws, and the emphasis on public order and state authority. The Roman approach to law, with its focus on practical governance and the protection of property rights, has influenced modern legal systems and criminological theories that prioritize the effectiveness of the criminal justice system and legal sanctions in deterring crime.

The enduring influence of these ancient philosophies is evident in contemporary criminological thought, which often embodies a blend of Greek and Roman ideals. Understanding the ethical and moral underpinnings from Greek thought, along with the practical and legal frameworks derived from Roman law, provides a comprehensive foundation for modern criminology. This blend of philosophical legacies enables a balanced approach to studying and addressing crime, combining considerations of individual morality and societal order with practical legal mechanisms.

Reflecting on the importance of these ancient philosophies underscores the necessity of a deep and nuanced understanding of the historical and philosophical roots of criminology. Such an understanding enriches the study of crime and justice, providing valuable insights into the development of effective, equitable, and humane responses to criminal behavior in modern societies.

 

Modification History

File Created:  08/04/2018

Last Modified:  01/21/2024

---

[ Back | Content | Next]

---

This work is licensed under an Open Educational Resource-Quality Master Source (OER-QMS) License.